Thursday, February 27, 2020

The Case for Being Judgmental


For some time, the label “judgmental” has been something that most Americans have sought to avoid being pinned on them.  It signifies intolerance in our relativistic age… “After all, who am I to judge?”.

The Sensible Conservative wears it as a badge of honor… as did our nation’s founders.  After all, to be judgmental is to have standards, whether they be moral or simply a sense of social propriety.  Without standards anarchy prevails.

But that observation, while true, is incomplete.  The vast majority of people have views of what’s right and what’s wrong.  What should be done and what shouldn’t be.  So humankind, mostly, I’m sure, have standards which, with varying degrees of success, they strive to follow.  Yet standards to influence others to adhere to them must be communicated outside of one’s self.  

However, it is an unfortunate fact that few in American society today have the courage to brave the approbation that greets the “judgmental” defender.

The Sensible Conservative believes this to be a crisis for America.

It used to be that religion and educational institutions and broader leaders of society served as heralds of good character and proper social conduct.  No more.  Most have simply abdicated the role, either out of modern relativistic attitude or fear of giving offense.

So what?

Our Founding Fathers (read The Federalist Papers) believed that a virtuous people were essential to the survival of a free republic.  They would have the character and judgment to make wise choices.  Of course, given the history of the past two centuries plus since then, that belief included naivete and hopes not always realized.

[Is it doubtful that a “current” Alexander Hamilton or James Madison would look with favor upon Donald Trump or Bernie Sanders.]

America needs a moral awakening.  Proper standards are not only right, they are essential to our society’s long term health – and, hence, survival.

          Values that matter:

                   Respect for others
                   Compassion for the less fortunate
                   The dignity of work
                   Self-reliance
                   Love of country
                   Devotion to family
                   Honesty

Values (the list is not meant to be all inclusive) require not only adherence but also promulgation.  Being judgmental can be a virtue.

No comments:

Post a Comment