When the Illusion of Hope Overcomes History

 

Mankind is undoubtedly tempted to forget the lessons of history and believe in the allure of hope.

This faith in what is often a tragic course was illustrated by a recent article in the New York Times about a growing appreciation in China for the writings of Mao Tse Tung.

Apparently, there’s great disenchantment among younger Chinese with the nature of their semi-capitalist, state-controlled society and economy.  Don’t the writings of the long dead “Teacher” (as Mao preferred to be called) with their promise of justice for the oppressors – and victory for the oppressed – hold out hope for a better future?

But how does one answer such ”understandable yearnings”?

History.  The words of promise became deeds of horror as Mao’s rule led to the death of millions of his countrymen (caused by forced famines, the Cultural Revolution, etc.)

But hope – as the expression goes – springs eternal and the experiences of the past are readily forgotten.  Anyway, believers who still remember will say we’ll do a better job next time to turn hope into the desired reality.

And human nature will change, too?

Optimism is a fine attitude.  We humans thrive when it is present.  But the virtue is often accompanied by the sin of hubris.  We are fools when we ignore reality.

The consequence are calamitous.  And so history repeats itself with predictable results.

Sometimes all the conservatives can do is follow the example of Jeremiah.  Tell the unwelcome truth.  Don’t be a fool.